THE

NORTHWESTERN REPORTER

VOLUME 117,

CONTAINING

ALL THE DECISIONS OF THE SUPREME COURTS

OF

MINNESOTA, WISCONSIN, IOWA, MICHIGAN, NEBRASKA,
NORTH DAKOTA, SOUTH DAKOTA.

PERMANENT EDITION.

AUGUST 4-NOVEMBER 17, 1908.

WITH TABLE OF NORTHWESTERN CASES IN WHICH REHEARINGS

HAVE BEEN DENIED.

ALSO,
ALPHABETICAL AND NUMERICAL TABLES OF NORTHWESTERN CASES PUBLISHED IN
VOLS. 135, IOWA REPORTS; 151, 152, MICHIGAN REPORTS; 103, 104, MINNESOTA
REPORTS; 76, NEBRASKA REPORTS; 16, NORTH DAKOTA REPORTS;

20, SOUTH DAKOTA REPORTS; 132, 133, WISCONSIN REPORTS.

A TABLE OF STATUTES CONSTRUED IS GIVEN
IN THE INDEX.

ST. PAUL:

WEST PUBLISHING CO.

1908.

Law Library

COPYRIGHT, 1908,

BY

WEST PUBLISHING COMPANY.

(117 N.W.)

NORTHWESTERN REPORTER, VOLUME 117.

JUDGES

COURTS REPORTED DURING THE PERIOD COVERED BY THIS VOLUME.

IOWA-Supreme Court.

SCOTT M. LADD, CHIEF JUSTICE.

CHARLES A. BISHOP.1
H. E. DEEMER.

J. C. SHERWIN.

OF THE

MICHIGAN-Supreme Court.

CLAUDIUS B. GRANT, CHIEF JUSTICE.

ASSOCIATE JUSTICES.

CHARLES A. BLAIR.
ROBERT M. MONTGOMERY.
RUSSELL C. OSTRANDER.

CALVIN L. BROWN.
CHARLES L. LEWIS.

E. R. DUFFIE.

JUDGES.

MINNESOTA-Supreme Court.

CHARLES M. START, CHIEF JUSTICE.
ASSOCIATE JUSTICES.

CHARLES B. LETTON.

E. C. CALKINS.

AARON V. MCALVAY.

EMLIN MCCLAIN.
S. M. WEAVER.
WILLIAM D. EVANS.2

NEBRASKA-Supreme Court.

JOHN B. BARNES, CHIEF JUSTICE.

FRANK A. HOOKER.
JOSEPH B. MOORE.
WILLIAM L. CARPENTER.3

1 Died July 9, 1908.

3 Appointed to succeed Bishop, J.

ASSOCIATE JUSTICES.

EDWIN A. JAGGARD.
CHARLES B. ELLIOTT.

SUPREME COURT COMMISSIONERS.

Department No. 1.

E. E. GOOD.
AMBROSE C. EPPERSON.
Department No. 2.

(111)

MANOAH B. REESE.

JESSE L. ROOT.

JACOB FAWCETT.

Resigned Sept. 15, 1908.

3